Blog Entry

WCHA got it wrong

Posted on: January 18, 2008 11:05 am

Many of you might have heard that the WCHA ruled on the Friday night Badger-Denver men's hockey game. Their ruling was, "we aren't going to do anything about it". This is a travesty on so many levels I cannot even begin to name them all.

For those who are not aware, the Badgers were down 3-2 with 3.7 seconds left to play. With .4 seconds Matthew Ford fo the Badgers scored the game tying goal. The referree's decided to review the goal on instant replay. After review the goal was disallowed. Apparently the referee used a freeze frame "still" picture in which the puck was in the crease and the clock said 0.00 on it. However that stil picture was a picture of the puck AFTER it had already hit the back of the net and bounced back out. The referee did not use the technology at his disposal and did not review any further. When reviewed PROPERLY it turns out he goal had counted and was in the net with 0.4 seconds left. Denver was awarded the points for the win and of course the Badgers were awarded no points. Keep in mind this was the end of the game with 0.4 seconds left. THe game was over as a center ice face off would not have allowed enough time to get a shot off (kind of like basketball when they say after 0.3 seconds there is not enogh time ot catch and shoot) so regulation was essentially over.

Here is where I really get lost. The WCHA head of officials AND the WCHA admitted a mistake had been made and the goal should have counted and they admitted so BEFORE the Badgers and Denver took the ice for their Saturday game. For those who do not follow college hockey, teams play two game series over the weekends, usually Friday and Saturday nights, so the controversy happened Friday night and the officials admitted there was a mistake on Saturday late afternoon. So please tell me WHY WCHA and NCAA officials, and the teams, could not have just agreed to play the 5 minute overtime period BEFORE the second game on Saturday night. I mean ther is only one five minute OT in college hockey and if it is still tied after that the teams both receive a point and it is declared a tie, it's not like they were going to play all night and it;s not liek it would have had a dramatic effect on Saturday nights game. This would have righted a wrong in an easy and fair manner. This was pointed out by announcers and thousands fo screaming hockey fans. So how come the supposed powers that be couldn't figure this out and get this right??? I know this, if the Badgers miss the NCAA tournament but one game, this season should have a proverbial asterik placed next to it's tournament. We have the technology why can't we get things right the first time???

Since: Mar 1, 2007
Posted on: January 23, 2008 2:40 am
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Aug 10, 2006
Posted on: January 18, 2008 3:58 pm

WCHA got it wrong

I get that there will always be bad calls. Fouls and other subjective things are tough and there will always be two sides to those. But in this case, this was definitive, this was easy to get right, this had OBJECTIVE video evidence to BACK UP tthe call that was made on the ice. Did I forget to mention that the refs called it a goal on the ice, that the goal light went off BEFORE the end of the period light went off. Did I mention the linesman backed up the call of goal on the ice. The video evidence should have jsut EASILY backed up the call that was made on the ice, but somehow this nimrod overturned the goal. Seriously, it is stuff like this that makes me think sports are not on the up and up all the time if you know what I mean.

Since: Feb 19, 2007
Posted on: January 18, 2008 1:25 pm

WCHA got it wrong

the badgers were basically the last team left out of the tourney last season. if it happens again im gonna freak out.

theres really no answer to your question though. bad calls have always been part of sports, and in the last 10 years or so bad replay calls have become part of sports.

and cb4p - i have another one for your list...


Since: Dec 20, 2006
Posted on: January 18, 2008 12:45 pm

WCHA got it wrong

We have the technology why can't we get things right the first time???

Sorry about that, Kaara.

I'm afraid I can only answer your question above with similar ones, like:

How many grains of sand are there in the Sahara?

How many licks are there to the center of a Toosie Roll pop?

How many angels can dance on the head of a pin?

They're all just really unknowable. If I had a dollar for every lousy call I saw over the years (whether or not it adversely affected my teams), I'd be Warren Buffett.



The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or