Blog Entry

Eye on Basketball Midseason Awards

Posted on: February 20, 2012 12:42 pm
Edited on: February 20, 2012 1:05 pm
LeBron James is having one of the best seasons of his career and is the midseason NBA MVP. (Getty Images)

By Matt Moore

The 2012 NBA All-Star break begins this week as this season continues to fly by on a shortened lockout schedule. Already we've seen an incredible year, even in the midst of some ugly, ugly, ugly basketball. The Heat look better than ever, the Bulls are still dominant through injury, the Sixers are impressively complete. The Dwight Howard saga drags on. The Lakers and Celtics are struggling to find their dominant gear. The Thunder are blistering offensively, the Timberwolves surprising and of course, Jeremy Lin, Jeremy Lin all the time. 

With that, here are the 2012 NBA Midseason Awards, based on where we stand on February 20th, 2012. 

Eastern Conference Most Valuable Player: LeBron James

When's Gregg Doyel wrote that LeBron was different this year, he was spot-on. James has talked about how he spent the summer re-discovering his love of basketball, getting away from all the criticism, and getting back to the person he wants to be. He and the Heat have admitted that the resounding backlash to "The Decision" played a large part in their mental approach to last season. In short, James is not comfortable being bitter, angry, resentful. He's at his best when driven by a simple love of the game. That's the dichotomy with James. He is inarguably the single most arrogant and out-of-touch player in the Association, and yet he does possess a genuine love of basketball. It's always playing at his home. It's something he lights up when he gets to talk about instead of storylines. Basketball came easily to James athletically, but it's also something he works obsessively at. History teaches that you have to hate your opponent, have to be driven by anger and resentment. James is simply not built that way. In reality, he may be too goofy, too fun-loving to ever reach the kind of iconic play that is necessary to be considered one of the best, to have the killer instinct that so many criticize him for lacking, which he himself has admitted he may lack.

None of this changes the fact that there are only three things which can stop James from earning his third MVP this season, should he continue to play as he has for the first half of the year. The first is largely the same reason he failed to win it last season: vengeance. Voters showed their disapproval of James by not truly considering him for the award. Whether it was a distaste for the arrogance of James' approach to leaving Cleveland on national television, a disgust at the preseason championship comments at the presser with the smoke and fireworks, or disappointment with James seeking to team up with two great players instead of winning on his own (an element neither Carmelo Anthony nor Chris Paul have received criticism for), James was shut out, when by most measures, he simply played better than Derrick Rose. Rose was a phenomenal player last season and a wonderful story, well-worthy of the award. However, James was better. Those sentiments have cooled this season, but if voters decide to maintain their teeth-grinding disapproval of James, that could cost him. The second is simple injury. James has only missed a small handful of games, but that can always derail a player's path. And the third is the most likely impediment: minutes.

The Heat did not take the tactic of prioritizing homecourt last season. It wouldn't have mattered, the Bulls were simply better in every way during the course of the regular season. But the Heat were clearly more focused on being healthy for the playoffs than capturing homecourt. And it's likely to be the same this year. The Heat have managed to handle the compact schedule well, outside of some Dwyane Wade bumps and bruises as to be expected. But when March rolls around, this team will start looking for rest, and that means James could sit out several games. The Heat will happily trade in April wins, provided they have a top four seed, for rest. James could lose momentum in that case as he watches from the sideline and another worthy candidate pushes his way to the finish line.

What makes James worthy of the award this year? Pick one. The Heat are the best team in the East, and you may claim that Dwyane Wade is still the focal point of the offense, metrics be damned, and that's fine, but James' overall work on both ends of the floor still takes the notch. Without resorting to statistics, you see James take over games as if he's a one-man army. He's seemingly everywhere, interrupting passes, working in the post, snatching rebounds, blocking shots, lobbing to Wade, dishing to Chalmers, attacking the rim over and over again. It's awe-inspiring basketball. You don't need metrics to see he's the best player in the game this season. This is all factoring in the fact he's taken a step back defensively. He's turned it on the past five or six games, but this hasn't been a season of his usual defensive dominance... and he's still been this good overall.

But if you want them, they bear it out as well. James is enjoying a career high (tied) in points per 36 minutes, rebounds per game and 36 minutes, field goal percentage, True Shooting percentage (factoring 3-point shooting and free throws), and of course PER. The confusion with PER most often is that it somehow measures value, that it establishes how good a player is. Instead, it's just what it's defined as. Player Efficiency Rating. It establishes who produces the most per minute, considering how many possessions they use in doing so. And right now, James is doing the most of any player in history in that department.

So that's fun.

James may not win MVP this year, for a variety of reasons. But there is absolutely no question at this season's halfway mark, that he's the best player in the league, and most valuable.

Western Conference Most Valuable Player: Kevin Durant

If you prefer the classic mold of the MVP, AKA a scoring machine, Kevin Durant fits pretty well. He's a jump-shooter shooting 52 percent from the field. Think about that. The league average is 36 percent. Durant is hitting 15 more shots for every 100 attempts from the hardest place on the floor to knock them down. That's ridiculous. That's just absurd. He is the best pure-scoring machine in the league. Kobe Bryant may topple him for the scoring crown, but he'll need five to six more attempts to do so. The cherry on Durant's Sunday has to be his 51-point explosion Sunday night. He managed 51 points on 28 shots.

And really quietly, Durant's become an elite defender. He's allowing just 26 percent from the field in ISO situations according to Synergy Sports. Defense was a huge weakness in Durant's game over the past few seasons and he's really hit his stride this season. The Thunder aren't even that great defensively, Durant has just been individually incredible.

For him to catch James, he would need for the Thunder to continue their impressive winning percentage. He would need to top the league in scoring, and for his impressive uptick in rebounding rates to continue. It's a tall order, but there's no question he's within range. Durant has become the most impressive offensive force in the league.

He is 23 years of age.

Rookie of the Year: Kyrie Irving

Ricky Rubio is dazzling. He's a phenom. He changes the course of games and wows you with the eyes. No rookie has impressed more than Rubio, who has silenced all his critics, of which I was very much one, regarding his ability translate his game to the NBA level. Rubio is honestly poetry in motion, and the feel he has for the game is joy-inspiring more than awe-inspiring. It is such a fluid and spectacular range of abilities, it makes the Timberwolves so much fun to watch.

And Kyre Irving is a better player.

It's not really close.

Get past the fact that Irving has been shooting at historic levels, that his overall production is in line with some of the all-time greats in this league in their first years. Irving has a mastery of the game that Rubio does not, even after so many more years of playing professionally. Irving can run an offense more completely and calmly, and is a superb crunch time scorer (Rubio is brilliant in that area in his own right). But if you want numbers, it's simple. Rubio's a 38 percent shooter. Irving is a 48 percent shooter. You can talk about how you would prefer your point guard pass than score, but Irving's numbers are truncated by a lack of talent on the Cavaliers, while Rubio has Kevin Love, Michael Beasley (a scorer for all his faults), an emerging Nikolai Pekovic and Derrick Williams.

Rubio would be a fine choice. He's the most exciting rookie. Maybe even the most impactful rookie.

Kyrie Irving is the Rookie of the Year, halfway through. This one will be tight to the finish.

Defensive Player of the Year: Andre Iguodala

I know. It's always Dwight Howard! It has to be Dwight Howard! But here's the thing. Howard's effort hasn't been as consistent this season. Whether it's the trade talk, the lockout schedule effect, coaching, whatever, it hasn't been there. His rebound rate is there, it's the highest of his career. He actually is allowing fewer points per possession than he did last year, but if we consider the lockout effects on all shooting percentages, Howard has slipped from the 96th percentile to the 77th percentile in rank on points per possession. Howard is maybe the most impactful defensive player in the league. But his performance hasn't been worthy of the award this year.

Iguodala, on the other hand, is the star defender on the league's best defense (Philly is tops in defensive efficiency, points per 100 possessions), and is most often given the toughest assignment night in and night out in this league. He is tasked with stopping the best perimeter threat on offense each game, and in doing so, has limited opponents to 35 percent shooting. He is able to body up larger opponents, stick with smaller ones, switch, shift, deter, block, steal, cajole, harass and otherwise make his opponent's life miserable and has done so for the majority of the season.

A close second on this list is Luol Deng, who actually has better marks via Synergy. But a combination of Deng's missed time due to injury, and the Bulls' reliance on help defense under Tom Thibodeau's system barely, and I mean barely, gives Iguodala the edge here. Dwight Howard will wind up winning this award, but ask yourself, is it more difficult to shut down perimeter elite scorers in this league or to stop the awful, horrible batch of big men currently roaming the lanes?

6th Man of the Year: James Harden

Harden should be starting. By any and all accounts, he is a much better player than Thabo Seofolosha, or Daequan Cook, or whoever you want to start at two-guard for the best offense in the land. Harden should be the starter, he plays starters minutes, he finishes like a starter, he's close with the starters, he's a star in his own right. And yet, he's much better off the bench. He provides the Thunder with not only a scorer off the pine, but an offensive creator, maybe his best asset. Harden can run the offense, he facilitates, and can make a play go even off-ball. He's a capable if not excellent defender, and his decision making and effort is often times the difference in close wins and losses for OKC.

This award has been wrapped up for a good long time.

Coach of the Year: Doug Collins

The Philadelphia 76ers have the third seed in the East as of this writing, with signature wins over the Lakers, Bulls, Magic, and just about everyone not from South Beach. Doug Collins has managed to turn a team without a central star, without an Isolation scoring threat, without a dominant big man or an all-world point guard (no offense to the brilliant Jrue Holiday) into a powerhouse that overwhelms teams with defense, savvy, bench scoring, team play, and fortitude.

The players genuinely love to play for Collins and he's gotten through to them to a man. Spencer Hawes is playing well, for crying out loud. Elton Brand is producing. Iguodala is having the best overall season of his career by the eye test. They have the best defense, the best bench, the best record in a tough division. Collins has done an incredible job and is every bit deserving of this award as much for his process as the results it has garnered.

Most Improved Player: Jeremy Lin

What were you expecting? Usually second-year players are exempt in my eyes. They're supposed to develop and improve in their second season. But Lin is a special case. Lost in the Linsanity and all the great storylines surround him is the fact he has talked a lot about what the D-League did for him. This league too often doesn't allow players to develop, simply shreds them through and only the strong survive. Lin is a testament to the idea that players can develop, can improve, can learn this game and get better to the point of success. He's improved the most simply by making himself relevant, let alone raising New York from the dead for 15 percent of the season.

Since: Jan 11, 2008
Posted on: February 23, 2012 9:14 pm

Eye on Basketball Midseason Awards

I'm not going to comment on who I think is the better ROY so far, cuz frrankly I don't know enough. What is hilarious to me is the argument that Irving has no one around him, and for Rubio he lists 4, count 'em FOUR, good players surrounding Rubio on the Wolves. Until now, I don't think the Wolves have EVER had that many players anyone would consider good, even in the year of their run to the West finals. Having a TEAM of good players, instead of 1 or 2 stars, is exciting for a Minnesota fan!

Since: Jul 24, 2011
Posted on: February 23, 2012 7:41 pm

Eye on Basketball Midseason Awards

I know I'm coming in late, but I hope you mean Irving, D-Dodd, Lebron is unlikely to be ROY.  First of all, let me just say that I believe Rubio should be ROY just so that 3 picks from the 2009 draft will have won the award.  Secondly, I think that if you're only going to consider numbers, then obviously you go with Irving.  Frankly, it's the easiest way to judge it.  However, I think that the team impact factor is being brushed off too easily here.  The Wolves have already matched their season win total from last year, even if Cleveland will eventually do it this year.  Cleveland may be in the playoff hunt because of the weak East, but Minnesota is legitimately in the hunt in the West.  The Wolves team is dynamic this year and to realize this much success after years of complete futility is far more impressive than putting up some of the best offensive numbers.

Since: Jan 17, 2007
Posted on: February 23, 2012 9:54 am

Eye on Basketball Midseason Awards

Twins, you have defined the criteria for why Lebron deserves the award. He is #1 in each of those 3 categories.

Since: Jan 29, 2009
Posted on: February 23, 2012 8:51 am

Eye on Basketball Midseason Awards


I get exactly what you are saying and Rubio has been great and the T'Wolves are much better this season because of his play on both ends of the court.  Rubio has played some very solid defense and Kyrie has struggled at times on that end so I will give you that one for Ricky.  However most awards are stat based and Kyrie continues to be consistent each night and he has elevated the level of play in Cleveland.  The Cavs already have 13 wins this year and are playing much better thanks to Kyrie.  Cleveland may not be a playoff team but they will win more games this season in a shortened year than they did last year.

Both players are great and it will be exciting to see how the rest of the season plays out.  The ROY race is not over so either player can step up the 2nd half of the year and take control.

Since: Jan 13, 2011
Posted on: February 23, 2012 12:00 am

Eye on Basketball Midseason Awards

I agree with Durant as west MVP (if OKC get NBA title he is MVP but, LBJ will get it before finalls) and Harden yes is THE 6-man of the year. Seems that NOW you are looking at OKC games, despite this week's power ratings I commented on today.

Since: Aug 29, 2006
Posted on: February 22, 2012 11:46 pm

Eye on Basketball Midseason Awards


Again, we should look on what defines the Rookie of the Year award. Is it the best statistical rookie in the NBA? Or is it the rookie who has the biggest impact on a winning team?

You forgot to mention that Rubio is #2 in the NBA in steals, as well. #5 in assists, #2 in steals, that's pretty darn good.

But yes, you're right. Kyrie Irving, statistically, is the RoY, but does the team's success do anything for a rookie? Because Rubio is starting for a team that's won as many games as it did last year, and we're only 35 games in.

I was just kind of bothered by the writer's double standards. 

Since: Jan 29, 2009
Posted on: February 22, 2012 12:10 pm

Eye on Basketball Midseason Awards

The Rookie of the Year race is close but the stats show Kyrie is playing better than Rubio so far.  Rubio is averaging 4 more minutes per game and Kyrie is still putting up 18.5 points, 3.5 rebounds, and 5 assists per game while shooting about 50% and Rubio is only averaging 11.5 points, 4.5 rebounds, and 8.5 assists while shooting about 40%.  Rubio gets the nice flashy assists while Kyrie has already had 2 game winners and consistently shoots well.

You don't win the ROY averaging 11 points per game and shooting less than 40% from the floor while your counterpart averages 18 per game and shoots just under 50%.  Kyrie is the leader for ROY and will more than likely win the award!

Since: Aug 29, 2006
Posted on: February 21, 2012 9:59 pm

Eye on Basketball Midseason Awards

Also, because Kyrie is clearly better than Rubio!
Where's your support? 

Since: Aug 29, 2006
Posted on: February 21, 2012 9:58 pm

Eye on Basketball Midseason Awards

If Rubio isn't Rookie of the Year because of the talent surrounding him, why is LeBron MVP?
Because Lebron "clearly" is the best in the game. Because Rubio isn't "clearly" the best rookie.

So the "Most Valuable Player" award is now the "Best Player" award? Why would it not have been LeBron James the last few years then? 

I'm not so sure I agree with that logic, Lomax66.

A) Statistics – points, rebounds, assists, steals, blocks, field goal percentage, free throw percentage, minutes, games played, and three point percentages are the building blocks. PER (Player Efficiency Rating), EFF (efficiency), and true shooting percentage are for the hard core geeks. The building blocks are reserved for media whores to easily examine. That is where the numbers are weighed heavily. There are more advanced statistics like win shares and +/-, but those are not weighed heavily by the majority.

B) Team record – The most valuable player has to be on a squad that has at least 55 wins at the end of the regular season. That team is usually top 2 – top 3 depending on year. The team record has to show win improvement from the previous year. If the team has 10-20+ games win improvement, the major media sports outlets eat that up fast.

C) Impact – This is also known as the “eye test.” Watch the games. Do not watch just one game. Watch as many as you can. Examine how the player is getting the job done. Look at his teammates. Then think, “Who does more with less?” Most importantly, observe how the player is taking over games.

With those criteria does LeBron "clearly" deserve the award?

Since: Nov 21, 2006
Posted on: February 21, 2012 9:08 pm

Eye on Basketball Midseason Awards

Rubio-Rubio-Rubio-Rubio. Love is playing great, but Rubio is the real new piece to the T'Wolves puzzle. More wins after 33 games than last year in 82.
THE DIFFERENCE IS.................................


Rookie of the Year---hands down.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or