Blog Entry

Quarterly Report Awards: LeBron leads MVP

Posted on: January 23, 2012 2:49 pm
Edited on: January 23, 2012 3:29 pm
James leads the pack of first-quarter MVP candidates (Getty Images)

This lockout-shortened NBA season is already a quarter over for most teams, stunningly. It has been a crazy whirlwind under the compacted schedule, and we're seeing older teams like the Mavericks, Lakers, and Celtics struggle through it. Meanwhile, deep, younger teams like the Nuggets and Sixers are thriving, and yet the same powers that were expected to be at the top are, even with Miami fallen off a bit. So to get a fix on where we are this season, we thought we'd hand out some awards, roundtable-style. 

1. Who's your MVP?

Royce Young: LeBron James. The Heat lost their first game without Dwyane Wade this weekend, but still, they're 5-1 without him and that's pretty much because LeBron is still the best player in the world.

Matt Moore: I don't want to say LeBron James, because it seems too obvious, but I'm going to say LeBron James, because it's so obvious. No one takes over those first 46 minutes like he does, and without them, you don't get to the time where he has so many question marks.

Ben Golliver: We’ve exhausted the ways to explain LeBron James’ individual brilliance in recent years, but the modifications that he’s made to his game – slashing his three-point attempts, improving his mid-range shot, getting to the free throw line more than he did last season – plus ridiculous numbers (29.7 points, 8.3 rebounds, 7.3 assists, 2.1 blocks, 56.4 percent shooting) make this James’ best season to date. Give it to him so we don’t have to listen to arguments in 5-8 years about how many times he was snubbed, like we’re been hearing from droning Kobe Bryant fans since 2006.

2. If star power wasn't a factor, just straight out "who helps their team the most," who's your MVP?

Royce Young: Still LeBron. I think it became pretty obvious last season how valuable he is to a roster when the Cavs went from a contender to the longest losing streak in NBA history just with the subtraction of LeBron.

Matt Moore: I think it's a tie between Gerald Wallace and Andre Iguodala. Both of those guys do such a phenomenal job in every facet of the game for their teams, and the wins and losses often correspond to how they come out. They're so active with and without the ball and make so many plays for their teams, they have a ridiculous level of impact on their teams, even if James is a superior player.

Ben Golliver: James’ PER ranking is 8 full points above the nearest competition (35 to Bryant’s 27) and he’s carried the Heat in Dwyane Wade’s absence due to injury, so his claim to “helping his team most” to date is essentially indisputable.

3. Is ROY a two-man race already?

Royce Young: Not yet. Ricky Rubio is the first quarter ROY, and Kyrie Irving is right there with him, but don't count out Kemba Walker and even Brandon Knight, who had quietly been playing well in Detroit early on.

Matt Moore: Rubio is drawing comments from people who say he is unlike anything they've ever seen and Irving is statistically dominant in nearly every category. If there were an award for Rookie to wind up making the most impact on wins and losses, I'd go with Kawhi Leonard, who will be making life very unhappy for some team in the playoffs.

Ben Golliver: We’ve definitely got the Ricky Rubio vs. Kyrie Irving two-headed monster that we expected, but the twist is that both the Timberwolves (11th in West) and the Cavaliers (9th in East) are fringe-y playoff teams rather than conference basement dwellers. Team performance could easily be the deciding factor.

4. If James Harden was starting like he should, who would be your sixth man of the year?

Royce Young: It's a close race between Al Harrington and Lou Williams. Both impact their teams greatly when they step onto the floor.

Matt Moore: Al Harrington. Harrington's ability to score anywhere on the floor combined with his active defense make him the prime candidate and it's not close.

Ben Golliver: Mo Williams of the Clippers has dealt with some injuries but has put up 14.5 points and 3.9 assists while shooting the ball extremely well (53.8 percent from the field and 44.8 percent from deep) during the season’s first month.

5. Who wins "worst coaching performance?"

Royce Young: Paul Westphal. Getting fired kind of seals your fate by default, doesn't it? But Westphal, who is a good basketball mind, just couldn't connect with his young team and lost them. That's not doing a good job.

Matt Moore: It pains me to say this because I think he's limited by his roster and will work out in the long-run for the Pistons, but Lawrence Frank has disappointed. Signing veterans with limite upside and impact isn't his fault, but relying on them is. The pieces are there for the Pistons to come together, but it simply hasn't so far this year.

Ben Golliver: I’ll give it to Flip Saunders of the Washington Wizards, if only because he was blown off so blatantly by referee Danny Crawford during this argument. He should have already been fired.

6. If we were giving an award for "strategic adjustment" by a team, who wins?

Royce Young: Rick Adelman has done the best job of any coach so far this season. The Wolves are finally organized offensively and he smartly managed the Rubio starting situation. He gave him time to ease in and made the move to start him before it became a nagging issue that was a constant topic of discussion.

Matt Moore: I'm going with Doug Collins' use of his bench. Deploying them as units and then integrating based on what's working in-game has been genius. Honorable mention to George Karl's two-point-guard lineup.

Ben Golliver: Completely disregarding defense was getting played out, so props to Mike D’Antoni’s Knicks for switching it up and completely disregarding offense.

7. Who has the best defense in the league, team and player?

Royce Young: The Bulls have easily been the best defense. Teams are having trouble cracking 80 on them for crying out loud. At home, they've held four teams to under 70. Best player, I'm giving credit to Andre Iguodala who had been terrific defending the perimeter so far this year.

Matt Moore: Chicago has the best team defense, but the Sixers' more basic, very stable set is a strong candidate as well. Dwight's the obvious pick, but with the Magic's overall defense not as hot, how about the Clippers' DeAndre Jordan? A block machine. He still overreaches on help at times, but overall he's been nearly dominant down low.

Ben Golliver: I think we’re at the same place we were last year: Chicago has proven itself to be the NBA’s best defense while Magic center Dwight Howard (16.1 rebounds, 2.3 blocks per game) is in a category all his own when it comes to individual accomplishments and impact.

Andre Iguodala has helped the Sixers to a surprisingly strong start. (Getty Images)
8. What wins "best storyline" for you?

Royce Young: The 76ers and Pacers quiet rise to contendership. Both teams don't really have any starpower and might not be able to sustain this success through the year, but they're playing well right now and positioning for a high seed in the East.

Matt Moore: The Knicks, Celtics, and Lakers falling apart like a flan in a cupboard. Nothing is more scinitllating that star-studded teams in big markets collapsing.

Ben Golliver: The Denver Nuggets and the Utah Jazz being so much better than the New York Knicks and New Jersey Nets, the teams who made blockbuster moves for Carmelo Anthony and Deron Williams at least year’s deadline.

9. Best free agent signing, first-quarter?

Royce Young: David West. He's given the Pacers exactly what they needed. An extra scoring option and someone to rely upon late in games for a big basket.

Matt Moore: Marc Gasol. Cheap out as he was re-signed, but Gasol has been even better than last year and looks like the franchise center he's being paid to be. Memphis made out huge with that deal.

Ben Golliver: Among the teams with the top records in the league, the Pacers adding David West – solidifying them as a likely top-4 team in the East – and the Clippers nabbing the amnestied Chauncey Billups – giving them a foul-drawing machine and a stand-in replacement when Chris Paul gets injured, both merit acknowledgement.

10. Who is the best team in the league?

Royce Young: Chicago. The Bulls are a bit boring -- especially when Derrick Rose doesn't play -- but you can't ignore how they're just hammering on people right now. Scoring against Chicago is a full on chore and with Luol Deng playing great, Carlos Boozer looking better and of course having Rose ready to carry the load when needed, the Bulls appear to have the total package.

Matt Moore: The Miami Heat. I know what the records say. I know how good Chicago and the Thunder have looked. But the Heat at their best are a better team than they were last year. OKC doesn't look as good, and Chicago is the same. Look me in the eye and tell me you're confident either of those teams can knock off the Heat if it's best vs. best. Chicago or OKC can both win the championship this season. The Heat are still the best team.

Ben Golliver: The Bulls are No. 2 in defense, No. 6 on offense and No. 1 in rebounding; their closest competition, the Thunder, are ranked No. 5, No. 14 and No. 16 in those categories. So far, this one isn’t as close as the records might indicate. I think Orlando – riding Howard and their point generating machine of an offense -- is a strong dark horse.
little ceasars
Since: Jan 1, 2009
Posted on: January 27, 2012 12:33 am
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Aug 19, 2006
Posted on: January 24, 2012 4:08 pm

Quarterly Report Awards: LeBron leads MVP

 Totally agree with you Dodd. All we heard about last year was how valuable Rose was to the Bulls , and how he almost single handedly makes them into an elite contender, yet here we are watching the Bulls dismantle teams without Rose in the line-up. Kinda changes your perspective a bit. Also you had the haters last year saying how the Heat were Wades team, and he's the real reason for their success, not James. Yet, Wade goes down and the Heat go on a run, they have beat the best most of the best teams in the league without Wade, so that's gotta boost LBJs MVP stock imo. Kobe is def. "contributing" a lot of shots, and usually when someone shoots a ton every night they are gonna get some points, but it seems to lead to a very disinterested Lakers squad. Kobe has the best and most expensive supporting cast in the NBA, yet he chooses to make it the Kobe show every night. Are we gonna get to the point we were at a few years ago where teammates were starting to comment on Kobes lack of team play? And Kobettes will tell you Kobe is getting assists too, but it's a bit misleading because he's demanding the ball constantly and only gives it up when he absolutely has to. Looks like the old Kobe is starting to rear his ugly selfish head.

Since: Jan 17, 2007
Posted on: January 24, 2012 10:49 am

Quarterly Report Awards: LeBron leads MVP

Nobody really thinks Kobe deserves the MVP over Lebron so far this year. Lebron is putting up stats the league hasnt seen in 30 years and the Heat is winning games. The MVP vote is really not even a question so far this year.

Also, I love how for the last 2 years we have heard how the Bulls are a one man team. Funny that this 1 man goes down, and they continue to win 80% of their games. Rose is a great player, but he is far from a one man show. In contrast, you see what happened to Cleveland when Lebron left last year. Now THAT was a one-man show.

Since: Mar 18, 2007
Posted on: January 24, 2012 4:02 am

Quarterly Report Awards: LeBron leads MVP

Can someone please explain to me how Rubio averages more assists, rebounds, and steals than Irving yet "Irving is statistically dominant in nearly every category"?

Since: Jan 22, 2007
Posted on: January 24, 2012 1:08 am

Quarterly Report Awards: LeBron leads MVP

Kinna like last season's... you can have all the MVBs you like but the ultimate goal is to win Championship. I like how Dallas is not getting the respect from sports commentators and teams.

Since: Dec 19, 2010
Posted on: January 23, 2012 9:45 pm
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Aug 19, 2006
Posted on: January 23, 2012 9:05 pm

Quarterly Report Awards: LeBron leads MVP

 Actually Miami is 5-1 without Wade, so how are they "losing"? You talk about James having Bosh, but fail to mention that Kobe has Bynum and Gasol... You make it sound like he's playing with scrubs. The Lakers have the highest payroll in the league, and they have for the last half dozen seasons, do you take that into account? Probably not. He is better in almost every single statistical category, and wayyy better in most, not to mention his efficiency is head and shoulders above Kobe, so how was it that Kobe is better again? I'm sure it is some hard to measure statistic that only Kobe fans know how to calculate. Talk about the rings all you want, but let's not forget that Kobe has been fortunate enough to play for the NBAs version of the Yankees for his whole career, money is no object. Your arguments are weak, just like smans grasp of basketball knowledge. Kobe puts up points by shooting 30 shots a game, always has always will. It isn't translating to Laker wins however, so is he really helping his team by hogging all the FG attempts? The W-L column disagrees with you, as does the statistics. FAIL.

Since: Feb 5, 2009
Posted on: January 23, 2012 8:35 pm

Quarterly Report Awards: LeBron leads MVP

These guys really don't watch a lot of basketball because they have their heads up their asses.  Kobe is more MVP than Lebron.  How is Lebron the MVP.  Even with Wade gone he still has the last 3rd of the big 3, Chris Bosh.  And Miami has been losing.  I don't care if Lebron has new post moves he still can't make the right decision in crunch time.  Sorry, for ROY I would put down Marshon Brooks.  Kawhi Leonard is a joke.  And Kyrie Irving has been inconsistent at best.  Rubio is the flavor of the month, but is also inconsistent.  Brooks is by far the most consistent, game to game.  Chicago does have the best team defense, but Dwight Howard is not the best defensive player.  He really isn't that great a defender.  Yeah, he blocks shots and gets rebounds, but he's not really a good man to man defender.  And the best team in the league is the Bulls, not the Heat.  You can't claim that the Heat, if they were full strength, are the best.  I used to have a friend argue that Charles Barkley was a better scorer than Jordan because he shot 60% from the field and if he took the same # of shots would score more.  Problem with that is its speculation and it never happened.  Right now, the Heat are not the best team.  They are losing easy games regardless of who's on the court.  The Bulls have been without D. Rose, now Deng, Noah, Taj Gibson, C.J. Watson.  Hell, they won with John Lucas III starting at point guard with D. Rose out.  If the Bulls can do it why can't the Heat.  Simple, the Heat is not as good.  CBS really needs to get some new NBA analysts because these guys suck.

Since: Aug 13, 2007
Posted on: January 23, 2012 7:37 pm

Quarterly Report Awards: LeBron leads MVP

Ben Golliver: Completely disregarding defense was getting played out, so props to Mike D’Antoni’s for switching it up and completely disregarding offense.

That's pretty funny.

Don't understand these guys all over LeBron for MVP. The Bulls are the best team and Derrick Rose is the best player. And I'm a Nuggets fan.

Since: Mar 14, 2011
Posted on: January 23, 2012 7:34 pm

Quarterly Report Awards: LeBron leads MVP

Zero Cool is off his meds again.  Props for a good rant, though.  Like it or not, Lebron's stats are better than Kobe's.  Points per game are roughly the same, as is steals, blocks, and three point percentage.  His rebounding and assists are a full two points better then Kobe's.  You claim that if Kobe were on crappy teams like Lebron, he would have asserted himself and averaged a triple double.  Not likely.  Kobe did play on a few crappy teams on the Lakers and his statistics stayed pretty much the same. (See Smush Parker, Chris Mihm, Von Wafer).  When Kobe is playing on a bad team, his points per game go up and his assists go down.  You could account for Lebron being a better rebounder than Kobe because of his size, but how would you account for a full two more assists per game?

Can I ask a favor of all the 11 year old fans out there that have jumped on the enormous bandwagon and hated on Lebron?  Can we get all of the play-on-words with Lebron's name out of the way?  Can we get it out of our system?
LeChoke, LeLose, Queen James, etc, etc,.  It's getting tiresome.  Can we comment on a player and use an original thought?

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or