Blog Entry

NBA Draft Fall Primer: Draft without a season?

Posted on: November 22, 2011 5:52 pm
Edited on: November 22, 2011 6:22 pm

By Matt Moore

The 2012 NBA Draft could very well be the most exciting draft since 2003. For starters, it likely could be the first NBA event since the 2011 Draft. It could be a random lottery. It could be weighted. There are a number of interesting variables, and that's before we get to the player pool.

With so many players backing out of the draft last season due to the NBA lockout, this class looks to be one of the most dominant classes in recent history. It would be one thing if it was just those returning players, though, but the freshmen also make up a significant upgrade over the past few years. NBA executives are licking their chops at a chance to get a hold of some of this talent, you know, when they have a sport for them to play in.

So to get you ready for the 2012 NBA Draft, consider this your Fall Primer as college basketball gets underway.

Contingency plans

If the 2011-2012 NBA season is lost, there are only a handful of ways the draft can go. Each has dramatic ramifications and will impact the careers of hundreds of players when factoring free agents and current players on rosters. Here are the options. 

1. No draft: If the two sides can't reach a settlement by late June when the draft is to be held, it's conceivable there would simply be no draft. This is a nightmare scenario as not only are we deprived of the dulcet tones of New York fans randomly jeering and heckling the commissioner, but guys that are ready to make the jump have to risk another year of injury in college. There would be an upside, obviously, with next year being an even bigger class as the studs of this class get another year to season. But it would also set franchises back to not have that draft class at all, especially if they're rebuilding. 

2. Take last year's lottery numbers and re-draw: This is obviously the favorite of the lottery teams, particularly those teams in most need of talent, teams like Cleveland, Minnesota (this protects their pick from Boston), and Toronto. Thing is, given that there's no way to tell what the impact of the last draft would have been on the season, the fight from other teams is going to be seen as legitimate. Who knows what Kyrie Irving could have done for the Cavs? What if Derrick Williams is a bonafide star? This helps the teams that need it the most (unless they've traded their pick), and since it would still be a lottery, would still leave things open for chance (can you imagine if Houston, barely missing the playoffs in 2011, managed to snag Davis, Barnes, or Sullinger?). 

The biggest reason this won't happen is that playoff and late-lottery GMs know the value of this draft. And they want a shot at it. Because rejecting this option opens the way for...

3. Equal-30-team lottery: Imagine you're the Lakers. The sun is setting on the run you had with Pau Gasol and Kobe Bryant. Bryant is still very much a viable star, but the overall makeup of the team is shifting, and needs to be built around Andrew Bynum, in all his flagrant-fouling glory. It looks like a hard road ahead. Until you land the No. 1 overall draft pick, allowing you trade Pau Gasol and still have Bryant, Bynum, and now either Anthony Davis, Jared Sullinger, Michael Kidd-Gilchrist, or Andre Drummond, should you go for the twin-towers approach. 

And the rest of the league shivered in their sleeping bags. 

This idea is going to be pushed by the elite teams, who are going to argue it's the only fair way to go about it, because of the number of unknowns losing a season presents. Boston could find the answer to what comes after the Big 3. The Bulls could land the second star Derrick Rose needs. Good teams could become great. Great teams could become elite. The ramifications are staggering. 

One team that doesn't improve in this situation? Miami. Cleveland has the option to swap picks in 2012 with the Heat, which would be pretty much the funniest thing ever if it's the Heat's pick in exchange for LeBron James that gives Cleveland the superstar of the future. 

This scenario results in mass chaos beyond all reason. Which is why the most-logical scenario is...

4. A three-to-five-year-weighted lottery: In this scenario modeled after what the NHL chose when it locked out for an entire season, teams are weighted based off their win-loss records over the past three-to-five years, depending on what the league opts for. The benefits are obvious. This rewards teams that have struggled over more than just last season and actually rewards the teams that have been historically bad. 

One team that would be royally damaged by this process is Cleveland. The Cavs would suffer based on the playoff success back when they had LeBron James and last season's epic disaster wouldn't be enough to offset it. On the other hand, teams like the Timberwolves, Kings, and potentially even Grizzlies would benefit a great deal from such an arrangement. Though it would be unfortunate, most likely, for Cavs fans, it does make the most sense, to the point you wonder why each draft isn't treated like this. It's a compromise based on both the elite and basement teams' desire to nab the talent in this class, and if we lose a season, it's the most likely scenario. 

The Kentucky Kid/Freakshow

Harrison Barnes may be the most complete player in the country. Jared Sullinger may be the most polished player in the country. Terrence Jones is a miniature beast. But the top of the draft? It's still kids, it's still freshmen, it's still Calipari, it's still Kentucky.

Anthony Davis has already endeared himself to rebuilding teams' fans all across the non-existent league. With a 7-4 wingspan he grew into after years of playing guard, Davis is able to move seamlessly from one end of the floor. He's active on defense and that wingspan allows him to block nearly anything. His offensive repertoire still raw as he learns to grow into his body, but off the pick and roll, he's been tremendous. Davis is the kind of raw, athletic talent that scouts and GMs drool over, and he's got the ability to back it up.

Davis is considered the No.1 draft pick right now in the eyes of NBA personnel, according to Jeff Goodman of

It's one thing to have the wingspan and athleticism that Davis has, but he's shown an early willingness to commit on the defensive end that few prospects do. The words "JaVale McGee" have been used, and not in the usual negative way, either. He's been a swat machine, with a 17.11 block percentage, which is ridiculous. 

He's the consensus No. 1 right now. He'll need to work on his offensive repertoire to cement his position, but as it stands, Davis looks like a superb No. 1 overall.

The Sullinger-Barnes Circus

Harrison Barnes was a potential No. 1 pick before last season started. But a slump to start the year put a damper on his prospect status. He recovered extremely well throughout the remainder of the year, and would have been a top-3 pick had he not decided to return to North Carolina.

Jared Sullinger, on the other hand, continues to rack up points as the "experienced" player of the draft, and one of the most dedicated to improving his game. Sullinger keeps losing weight, understanding that at the pro-level, his humongous hindquarters won't help him in establishing post position as easily and that he'll need to be a svelt combo-forward to get minutes. It's the kind of self-awareness scouts rarely see and often covet.

The draft is always a youngest-man game, with teams wanting to oversee as much of the players' development as they can. But Barnes and Sullinger will be vying in the top five for which has the most impact as the more "polished" or "complete" product. Sullinger represents the more "polished" aspect with comparisons being drawn of Zach Randolph and Brandon Bass, while Barnes is the more highly touted prospect, and is considered the most "complete" player in the draft. If Davis is the wunderkind who you can't wait to see what he becomes, Barnes is the most "OK, I know where that guy fits right away" player at the top of the board.

Stacked Competition

When North Carolina faces Kentucky in Lexington on December 3rd, there will be ten legitimate prospects on the floor. Davis, Michael Kidd-Gilchrist, Terrence Jones, Doron Lamb, and Marquis Teague for Kentucky, Barnes, John Henson, James McAdoo, Tyler Zeller, and Kendall Marshall for UNC. That game basically is the draft combine.

But Baylor with Perry Jones and Quincy Miller will face Thomas Robinson and KU, as well as Myck Kabongo and Texas and LeBryan Nash and Oklahoma State. There are a number of matchups this year pitting top talent against top talent, the perks of having so many quality returning players.

More unanswered questions than usual

With a draft as exciting as this one, the questions that abound have more impact than the usual amount of unknown quantities in any pool of prospects.

Is Andre Drummond too raw to be a lottery pick this year?

Is LeBryan Nash a headcase?

How much of Thomas Robinson's aggression and explosiveness will translate when he's been listed as small as 6-8? (NOTE: A Nike camp measurement from this past summer listed him at 6-10 with a healthy wingspan of 7-1.)

What position is Terrence Jones going to play in the NBA and more importantly, did Josh Smith clone his brain and insert it into him?

Is Michael Kidd-Gilchrist actually the best prospect on Kentucky?

Will Austin Rivers be ready to make the leap when he has such a steep hill to climb in terms of point guard skill?

We'll be tracking these questions and many more throughout the college basketball season as part of our draft coverage. There's no NBA at the moment. But the next generation of players is ready to put on quite a show.


Since: Feb 9, 2007
Posted on: November 25, 2011 11:39 pm

NBA Draft Fall Primer: Draft without a season?

Patric Young. This dude should've been featured in this article. When OSU and UF played, he outplayed Sullinger. Young is 6'9 and built like Dwight Howard.
You realize you just described Joey Dorsey right?

Since: May 24, 2010
Posted on: November 25, 2011 10:15 pm

NBA Draft Fall Primer: Draft without a season?

Don't even give that d-bag David Stern the idea of an equal weighted draft!  I am sure he would love that idea and if that were to happen, somehow and mysteriously, the draft order would look something like:

1) New York Knicks

2) Los Angeles Lakers

3) Boston Celtics

4) Miami Heat

5) Chicago Bulls

6/7) How may throw New Jersey a bone since they are moving to New York / The Clippers (They are in LA after all and they need a break or two)

8-30) Everyone else

Now, under this scenario is there were said to be 10 elite prospects (and I know the draft is a crap shoot) but let's say their were 10 elite prospects the top of the draft would look the same but again, mysteriously the second 10 would start like this:

11) Minnesota

12) Sacramento

13) Milwaukee

14) Toronto

and so on....

I like the weighted average draft (3-5 year) though it does punish Cleveland the most but with the way they magically turned that #8 pick from the Clippers into #2 and Kyrie Irving, I would say Stern already hooked them up enough to make up for it.

I am sure there will be a season even if it is a half one, though I wouldn't necessarily mind if there weren't.  I think most fans are pretty much done with it by now and are like me, just wake me up when they get a deal done!

Since: Nov 23, 2008
Posted on: November 25, 2011 8:31 pm

NBA Draft Fall Primer: Draft without a season?

Gee, if there were no draft at all, maybe with that extra year of school some of the first round picks would be able to learn to read.

Since: Jun 4, 2008
Posted on: November 25, 2011 1:51 pm

NBA Draft Fall Primer: Draft without a season?

Patric Young. This dude should've been featured in this article. When OSU and UF played, he outplayed Sullinger. Young is 6'9 and built like Dwight Howard. 

Since: Sep 20, 2008
Posted on: November 24, 2011 8:28 pm
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Sep 1, 2006
Posted on: November 24, 2011 3:31 pm

NBA Draft Fall Primer: Draft without a season?

If there was no draft, what would happen to the 2 or 3 seniors that might have been taken in the draft?

Since: May 25, 2009
Posted on: November 24, 2011 3:26 pm

NBA Draft Fall Primer: Draft without a season?

Although this would make a nice article under the "what if the NBA did have a lockout?" category, writing it now is a waste of your time Mr. Moore.

You see, just reading it is painful. Throw in the fact that the average fan has left and left for a while, what your reduced to is the pathetic followers with no other factor in their life.

No one gives a crap about the NBA draft now. No one cares about a 66 game season. Heck, 66 games??? That ranks up there with the last NFL lockout. No one cares about the "charity" games or the Obama "classic". Just suckers.

Off to eating Turkey and some skeet shooting.  

Since: Jun 14, 2008
Posted on: November 24, 2011 9:58 am

NBA Draft Fall Primer: Draft without a season?

If the NBA wants to survive they would need to have a draft. Think of the excitement in the colleges if all the stars had no where to go! The mid majors would be able to pilfer some top talent away from the elite programs, and parity may extend deep into the big conferences. The NCAA would have the product the NBA has been dreaming about.

Since: Jul 23, 2011
Posted on: November 24, 2011 9:32 am

NBA Draft Fall Primer: Draft without a season?

Looking ahead to what the next NBA draft may hold is natural because with most sports fans the future holds hope.  Basically sports fans are optimists; our team may suck today, but next year....However, the basic assumption here is that nothing is going to change.  The NBA will have a collective bargaining agreement that changes the way the pie is divided but the pie remains the same.  At one time there was talk of requiring two years of college in order to both produce a more mature, well rounded rookie and to build up more public recognition of who these young phenoms are.  That apparently has gone by the boards in the battle over money.  So next June we will most likely hold the draft as has been the tradition.  Anthony Davis will go first and nothing much will have changed.  We'll have the same old NBA.  At what point will people stop caring, watching, and mortgaging their homes to be able to afford tickets?

Since: Feb 7, 2007
Posted on: November 24, 2011 12:36 am
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or