Blog Entry

Jazz trade Deron Williams, but why right now?

Posted on: February 23, 2011 12:29 pm
Edited on: February 23, 2011 12:30 pm
Posted by Royce Young

It took four excruciating months of hemming and hawing for Carmelo Anthony to get traded to the Knicks. It took a little less than 30 minutes for Deron Williams to go to the Nets.

In a stunning blockbuster, New Jersey acquire Williams, Utah gets Derrick Favors, Devin Harris and two first-round picks. A third team was used as the Warriors get Troy Murphy for Dan Gadzuric and Brandan Wright.

The Nets chased Anthony for four months, trying to schedule meetings, trying to convince him to sign an extension. And after it all fell apart, that's when they got to work. Instead of bringing in Melo, the Nets one-upped the Knicks and got a cheaper and better player in Williams. Mikhail Prokhorov said he didn't care about the Melo situation in Los Angeles. Well, I guess we know why now. Because their Plan B was way better than Plan A.

Everyone is going to talk about the Nets and what an insanely slick move this is. They just nabbed one of the top players in the league and arguably the best point guard for less than they were going to give up for Melo. It's a terrific deal for New Jersey. Like, it couldn't be better.

But on the other end, people in Salt Lake City haven't moved for the last hour. A couple hundred thousand jaws dropped in unison. Deron Williams is gone. Their franchise player, gone. Just like that. And only a couple weeks after Jerry Sloan resigned after 23 years at the helm in Utah. At this point I think you could relocate the franchise and it would be less of a stomach punch than this.

So why? Why was Williams moved now? Why so soon after Sloan's resignation? Are the two things related? So, so many questions.

Williams was already being brought up in talks that he wanted to go to New York in 2012 when he could opt out of his contract, as reported by Ken Berger. So really, the Jazz had the rest of this year and then one more guaranteed season with Williams. And we know what was coming in 2012. Deron Williams would most definitely be the new Carmelo Anthony. Questions every day about his future, rumors flying constantly out of Salt Lake -- it was going to happen.

And the Jazz played their trump card early. They nipped it in the bud. Instead of spending half a season dragging themselves down with trade and extension talks, the Jazz just got rid of the problem before it started.

Utah wasn't going anywhere this season. The offseason move of acquiring Al Jefferson wasn't working out and the team had been slipping since December. Really, this year was kind of a lost cause. Utah could look forward to next year, but again, it would be a year of Derondrama, and that wanted to be avoided. So a deal was made.

Clearly, general manager Kevin O'Conner wasn't confident in Utah's chances of re-signing Williams. I don't need to say that because it's pretty obvious with the deal. But the Jazz aren't a franchise that gets played. They've been successful for a quarter of a century with only a few minor hiccups here and there. They absolutely did not get back equal value for Williams, but they did get a solid package. They'll have to rebuild, which is something they aren't scared of doing.

Because now, Williams is New Jersey's problem. There's no guarantee (that we know of yet) of him signing an extension with the Nets. I'm sure Prokhorov and Billy King figure that will happen, otherwise they don't make this deal, but we don't know for sure. By the sound of it, Williams wasn't really asked. Jazz radio man David Locke tweeted that it wasn't Williams' choice to move and that he was stunned by it. So are we, Deron.

On top of it all, Williams was a bit of a problem child. He had major dust-ups with Sloan, didn't always get along with management and ownership and while he completely embraced the Jazz and Utah, he had some attitude. And the Jazz aren't an organization that routinely works through those type of things. So when you start to pile all of this on top of each other, it starts making more and more sense.

There's potential this works out for Utah. They loved Favors before the draft, got a quality point guard in Devin Harris and two first-round picks that will likely be high. They foundation of Utah has been shaken if not destroyed over the past month, but there's a clear effort to rebuild. And I guess it had to start with getting rid of the team's best player. Williams helped nudge Jerry Sloan out the door and just a few weeks later, he was packing too.

But here's the good news Utah: You've just got a lot better chance at getting Jimmer Fredette now.

Since: May 27, 2007
Posted on: February 23, 2011 10:04 pm

Jazz trade Deron Williams, but why right now?

Jazz season ticket holder:  i was not going to renew my seats for next year.  now i will.  my ticket agent told me her calls and emails say i am in the majority.

Since: Apr 21, 2009
Posted on: February 23, 2011 5:50 pm

Jazz trade Deron Williams, but why right now?

You want to know why the trade happened right now?

This article pretty much sums it all up:

Since: Aug 18, 2006
Posted on: February 23, 2011 5:21 pm

Jazz trade Deron Williams, but why right now?

I've seen more bitter comments by Knick fans more than anything else. It seems that the only one's that are calling this a bad trade for the Nets ...Are Knick fans, wow...just least try to hide how bitter you are.  
D.Will will be playing the next 8-10 years in Brooklyn, the heart of NYC basketball.

Since: Sep 11, 2007
Posted on: February 23, 2011 4:56 pm

Jazz trade Deron Williams, but why right now?

deron williams and carmelo anthony are not comparable because they are such different players (position, skillset, etc.).  however, the nets have not significantly upgraded an already terrible squad.  they didn't even get Dwill long-term.  what if they continue to be horrible (likely) and he wants out as a free agent in two years.  Perhaps they should've kept all of their picks and built around Harris, Lopez, and Favors.  Instead of taking a flyer on a guy who will probably be gone after next season.

Since: Feb 4, 2011
Posted on: February 23, 2011 4:01 pm

Jazz trade Deron Williams, but why right now?

How is he superior? He plays a totally different position, and now New Jersey has Deron Williams and who else, they just traded their future, and Harris looks pretty good.

Since: Apr 13, 2007
Posted on: February 23, 2011 3:24 pm

Jazz trade Deron Williams, but why right now?

Yeah, except for the fact that Deron Williams is a superior player to Carmelo Anthony.  Besides that though you might be on to something..

Since: Aug 21, 2006
Posted on: February 23, 2011 3:04 pm

Jazz trade Deron Williams, but why right now?

This is actually pretty stupid of the Nets.  Give up Favors and two first rounders to upgrade the position they were already strongest at for a guy that will only be there one more year (player option in 2012), for a team that is garbage.  This reeks of desperation to match a marquee move by the Knicks.

LOL...  Yes cause they were showing such great signs of improving with the group they had. You can build a team around Williams.

Since: Mar 18, 2008
Posted on: February 23, 2011 3:01 pm

Jazz trade Deron Williams, but why right now?

This just shows me that the Jazz had given up on this season and are looking to the future. I can't say this for sure, but I highly doubt this organization would be in this situation if Larry Miller were still alive. So in less than one season, the Jazz give up Boozer, Mathews, Korver, Brewer, Williams and two coaches in Sloan and Johnson? I think what's so difficult to swallow for us Jazz fans is that this organization has been as consistent as the sunrise for nearly 25 years, and now it is a shade of its former self. Look for the Jazz to drift into lotteryville ala LA Clippers and small market obscurity. With the rumor of contraction out there, I wouldn't be surprised to see the Jazz go the way of the Supersonics. Greg Miller and Kevin O'Connor are TERRIBLE. Way to trash a great franchise, guys!

Since: Jan 2, 2008
Posted on: February 23, 2011 2:28 pm

Jazz trade Deron Williams, but why right now?

I am very close friends with a couple Jazz fans and they are HAPPY he's gone. And elated they got so much in return. I think they got equal value. Jazz fans love Sloan, they see Deron as the villain and could care less that he's gone.

Since: Feb 23, 2011
Posted on: February 23, 2011 2:28 pm

Jazz trade Deron Williams, but why right now?

Great move for Utah!  DWill was quickly becoming a cancer on the team.  Nip it in the bud, move on.  Three years from now there will be an article written about how this was a better trade for Utah than New Jersey.


Goodnight and thank you Señor DWill
You've completed your task
What more can we ask of you now?
Please sign the book on the way out the door
And that will be all, if we need you we'll call
But I don't think that's likely somehow...

("Goodnight and Thank You," from Evita )

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or